Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Did we ever bother to know Muzzammil?

Muzzammil Hassan, the owner and CEO of Bridges TV has been arrested for beheading his wife, Aasiya Zubair.

Inna lillahi wa inna ilaihi rajaiun, indeed everything belongs to Allah (God) and to Him we will return.

This is the news of the year that has once again damaged not only the Muslim image in American society, but it has also damaged our trust and the hope that we place in American Muslim leadership.

It’s been five days now that my family along with the rest of the community has been in shock. The fact that Muzzammil was married to my first cousin before marrying the victim still horrifies us. Ms. Zubair was his third wife. Both of his earlier wives filed divorce on the same grounds of severe domestic violence and abuses.

My cousin lived with him for only a year. Yet, it took her several years to get rid of the fear of living with a man in marriage. He was known as violent and abusive in the community. He had changed his name from Syed Muzzammil Hassan to Mo Steve Hassan. He had no background of community service or involvement in the Mosque or in any other organization. Neither his character and nor his faith were sound. In addition, he had no background or expertise in TV production or media.

But it did not matter. Even with this bad reputation, horrible background and lack of experience in media market, he still got the stage at the most reputable American Muslim conventions. Our leaders and established organizations did not bother to vet him. No questions or flags were raised about him. He was introduced at these conventions with huge respect and the Muslim community was told to give him generous funds for Bridges TV.

The American Muslim community, desperate for its own English channel in the United States, said yes to the call and collected millions of dollars and handed it over to him. I personally know people who collected fifty thousand or more in a day or two for this cause. It was not Hassan, the donors but trusted the organizations standing behind him.

Muzzammil Hassan put that money in his personal pocket and moved into a huge property with stables and horses. Nobody was there to question that how much money was spent on the actual project and how much was spent on his new but lavish lifestyle. None of our organizations bothered to look into it and inform their members of any concerns.

I was mostly in Pakistan in that period. After resigning from NBC News, I went to Pakistan for a couple of years. I was working as General Manager of The City Channel of ARY Digital in 2004, when I heard about the Bridges TV. I thought it must be a project of Islamic Broadcasting Network or Sound Vision Foundation. But I was surprised to hear that none of our longtime organizations were part of this channel and nobody knew the owner for long time.

The surprise was changed into shock and worry when I learned that Bridges TV was owned and operated by the same Muzzammil Hassan who I knew as a serious criminal. To me domestic violence is a serious crime and a person’s character must be judged by the way he deals with his family. At my return, I warned some community leaders, but the response was not encouraging. People told me that his personal life may be messed up, but he is doing a good job so we should support him no matter what.

This support was so overwhelming that he was presented with awards too. Now the pictures of award ceremonies are coming back to haunt us and some of them are already posted on anti-Muslim blogs after the murder of Ms. Zubair. One of the headlines reads: Bridges TV CEO Arrested for Beheading Wife Received Award from … [name of a prominent national American Muslim Organization].

Bridges TV’s website requests to respect family’s privacy. In this case, unfortunately, this request cannot be honored. There is no privacy for people who promote themselves as leaders of the community and take people’s money on the promise of investing it in the community projects.

This murder might not have cost us as much if Muzzammil was just an ordinary Muslim. Instead, unfortunately, he was a trusted and respected member of the American Muslim community.

The Vice President of Islamic Society of North America, Imam Mohamed Hagmagid Ali, has posted an open letter on ISNA’s website. He writes, “Our community needs to take strong stand against abusive spouses and we should not make it easy for them to remarry if they chose a path of abusive behavior.”

What about making community leadership easy for them, Imam?

Shouldn’t Islamic organizations also take responsibility of vetting new comers before presenting them on the stage? Common people rely on organizational leadership and judgment.

Vetting of community leader has been established since the time of Prophet Muhammad (may peace be upon him) and is now in practice within the conscious communities all over the world. The Obama administration is going through the same process. Whenever it is not done properly it causes trouble and embarrassment as we have recently witnessed in the case of former Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle.

It’s always better to be safe than be sorry. It’s important for the American Muslim organizations to improve themselves on this ground too. We have no option but to live up to this standard.

As my heart goes out to Aasiya’s family and children, I recognize this not only as their personal loss, but as a huge loss for our American Muslim Community at large: A loss of a project needed now more than ever before; a loss of financial resources that can never be collected again with the same trust and passion; and a loss of respect for an American Islamic channel and the intentions behind it.

May Allah forgive us for our shortcomings. May He grant us patience and replace the loss with something better and beneficial, amen.

43 comments:

  1. More people need to come forward with this type of information in the beginning. I know of several other shady individuals that are seen as 'heros'...yet no one wants to do anything about it

    ReplyDelete
  2. May I repost this, with permission, on hijabman.com?

    Your words need to be read.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Muslim communities need to establish organizations like Hamdard in Chicago and Adam Mosque in DC which provide counselling, educate our communities about family and social issues and provide support to vulnerable people of our community.

    We are already too late and have caused enough damage to last two generations of our communities in America.

    At the least invite the founders of these organizations in to your areas and provide your leadership some education on this subject to make them aware of the magnitude of these issues in our communities.

    Sister Zerqa, thank you for your continous good work.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is very disturbing and even NOW there are people who want to keep their head in the sand and hush this over!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think fear is at the root of the general air of complicity in the Muslim communtiy. Muslims are paralyzed by the fear of loss...losing face, losing position, losing material comforts, losing money, losing friends,losing time, losing connections, losing control. We refuse direct critical analysis of ourselves and others. We cover everything with 'hamdulillah' and 'inshallah' without taking the action is a requirement of those words. Remember how often Rasulullah was questioned regarding his merits and he always responded to his people with the evidence they needed...without anger or hostility. Now, however, there is an 'untouchability' that surrounds any position of authority regardless of the merits of the person who holds it...be it parent, teacher, community elder etc. Leadership in the Muslim community is not necessarily 'earned' as it should be. We have to remember there is a difference between giving someone 'respect' and giving them 'power'. 'Respect' is not earned as they say in the West...it is freely given to everyone from each tiny infant to every elderly grandparent and everyone in between...regardless of merit. Some receive a deeper respect than others based on position. 'Power' is different. 'Power' something we give to those who have proven their ability to use it responsibly...based on merit. Leadership means 'power'. All positions of leadership should be filled based on a candidate's potential use of power...as a husband, mother, teacher, leader etc. Unfortunately, some people do not deserve 'power over others' even in common roles as parents or spouses. We have to stop confusing the two concepts. We have to reserve even the smallest amount of power for leaders who will serve those under his/her power and restrict it from those who will weaponize the power we give them. This can only be accomplished with due diligence in making those appointments... aka real research, acceptance of social/political/personal risk, progress in the face of fear. As a community we have to take responsibility for our condition...the Hassan family being a tiny cell in the community as a whole. As in most conflicts, the role of victim and victimizer are played by all at different times and in different degrees. Inshallah, we will heal and be healed through this situation. Inshallah, we will now step very carefully into relationships, both intimate and public, as individuals and communities. What we help create will return to serve us or harm us in the end. My heart breaks for the small children born of this marriage. They are the only truly innocent victims in my mind. Such a tragic incident between parents could haunt a person well beyond childhood. They have a lot of work to do and it will be uphill for a long time. Allah has chosen them for a daunting task that none of us will fully understand. I believe that in part they are in this situation because we let them down. I hope as a community we wrap our love around them. Their parents are beyond helping them and THEY ARE US... now, before this happened and always.
    Wa salaam...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for this post, its very honest and realistic, for too many in our community the only thing that matters is the superficial appearance of the person (not just physically, but if they go to the mosque for a short while then all of a sudden what they say matters more than someone else involved in the community). This needs to stop, people need to be more open to understanding that not everyone is on the same page when it comes to how faith is practiced, and that what matters is their benefit to our community.
    This man is a disaster through and through, a horrible abusive person who has nothing to do with our religion, but now we have to deal with yet another horrific smear on our community thrown all over the news. This animal should have been put in jail years ago, and his abuse of his former spouses not shrugged off as it so often is in the community.
    Thanks again for your post, its great.

    ReplyDelete
  7. As difficult as it is to do, we have to try very hard to focus our energy and action on the crimes, not the criminal. We must love for this brother what we would love for ourselves. For myself, I would love to have a way back from this darkness I had created around me and my children. I would love to have even one person who would continue to offer guidance and truth even to my last breath. 'Horrible, abusive person', 'disaster' and 'animal' are words that come to all our lips but we have to leave space for something bigger. Remember, the Sahabah buried their innocent baby girls alive, Hind ate the liver of Hamza. Human beings have an enormous capacity for monstrous behavior and an enormous capacity to recognize light after darkness. We have to remember that this man is the father of 2 very tiny, vulnerable little people. What if somehow a door to Islam was left open for him and he walked through it in 5 years, 10 years from now? There is nothing to be lost from removing him from the power to harm but standing steady and ready for a miracle. His children will at some point connect their own worth to the worth of their father...it is a stage we have all passed through. Better to gift them with hope and the chance at redemption that Allah has promised all of us until the day we die.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am a muslim man and I say reform it, call out the things that are wrong, dont hide behind historical 'hatiths etc' this is 2009 and we need to change Islam from within.

    In pakistan and elsewhere muslims terrorist are killing other innocent muslim in the name of god. There is really something wrong and we need to stand up an fight this evil within our culture. Honor killings and domestic violence is terrorism and we need to stop hiding from the fact that, people are using Islam for evil.

    I donated lot of money to BridgesTV and I will continue supporting them, but we need to monitor all the muslim organizations an root out evil.

    I hope the whole American Muslim community feels ashmed about this character and we root out all evil characters from within without exception.

    Ameen

    ReplyDelete
  9. Smarty,

    You sound like a NeoCon in your approach to this matter. I agree that we need to root out evil and wrongdoing. The way to do that is by going back to the true teachings of Islam. The reason for this tragedy and all the ills of Muslims and their communities is that we -individually and collectively- are not following the Quran and Sunnah, as we should be. You have to be careful when you say reform, because again the way to reform ourselves and our communities is to behave as we should be and going back to our teachings that we ignore under many excuses. May Allah {swt} make us able to adhere to true Islam, stay away from un-Islamic cultural interference, guide us to the straight path, forgive our sins, grant us His mercy, and gather us in jannah, Ameen.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Zerqa, I understand your dislike of this man given his history with your cousin and what he has purportedly done to Aasiya.

    However, I wish you checked some of your facts before writing this. Some of the inaccuracies with respect to Muzzammil's lifestyle, finances and religious sentiment are incorrect and unfair. Perhaps because you were in Pakistan in this period, you have based your information on hearsay.

    I also don't believe his history of abuse was as widely known in the community as you report. Even in your cousin's case, very few people in Rochester NY (where they lived at the time,) knew of the problems she faced. Also he did not change his name to "Mo Steve"; he only used Mo, and that too as a nickname.

    I can tell you this because I knew Aasiya, your cousin, the children and Muzzammil. My heart bleeds for Aasiya and all four of the children, but at the same time I do not think a responsible journalist like you should misinform the world.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Painfilled Heart,
    We have to go back to the basics of Islam. This is a perfect example of Allah's way of doing things. He shows us examples, sometimes of role models and other times of people we should not model after. Now that this example is in front of us, what are we going to do about it? Are we going to discuss this incident at every occassion till we find something new to DISCUSS or are we going to take some physical action. Unless we connect ourselves wholly and solely with the teachings of the Quran and Sunnah, nothing will change. The truth is that there are no two ways about it : Either we are in or we are out!
    "God, grant me the Serenity to accept the things I cannot change, Courage to change the things I can, and Wisdom to know the differnce."
    We need to first look within ourselves and make the necessary changes in the light of this horrific incident, then we need to work our way out into the Muslim Community as helpers and educators. Education has to be in the light of the Quran and Sunnah. THIS IS THE ONLY WAY TO SUCCEED!!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dear Anonymous,

    I do not write about any matter before doing my homework. I had checked my facts before. If you don't know that he had changed his name to Mo Steve Hassan, you really don't know them, so please do not confuse people. This name was actually used on many of his mails and documents that he received on daily bases.

    About his lifestyle: In addition to what I know because of many relatives in the area, Aasiya's own interviews in different magazines and newspapers reflected the same. Just pick up an old copy of Azeezah magazine and you will hear it from their own mouths. If you know them for long time, you should know that how were they living prior to Bridges TV.

    People in Rochester, NY, at the time of my cousin's divorce knew about the reasons, but typically a woman's condition is taken less seriously in all these cases. People were aware about the complaints of both wives, and many people felt sorry for Aasiya when she first arrived. I know people who would like to stop Aasiya's parent if they had known about the third marriage in advance. I hope you also open your eyes and ears from here and start paying attention to a man's character by checking his background not by his marketing skills.

    My intention of writing this blog was not to dig in his personal life; instead I wrote to aware our community leaders to check a person before presenting him on stage. To establish that case, I am also pointing out that he was not involved in any mosque or community organization over a noticeable period. We can say that it's hard to know about bedroom life (which was obvious in his case), but we cannot say that it was hard to find out about his community affiliations and services.

    That is the root problem in this case. Our loss is bigger than a personal loss just because we did not vet him in time. The least we can learn from here is to demand a track record from our leaders and to monitor them closely. InshaAllah, we will be better off.

    I hope this helps

    Regards,
    Zerqa

    ReplyDelete
  13. What I do not understand is why Zerqa waited until now to expose Hassan. Why did not she write about him like she is doing now. This could have been prevented. He kept finding girls to marry him even after the previous ones were abused. Aasiya had to pay the price of this silence
    Those who remained silent and did not expose Jassan are blaa
    Blame wothy too

    ReplyDelete
  14. What ever happen is very sad and hurtful. I have one question to all of you. Did any body know if he was abusive or instead of any men to be called abusive. what makes someone cross the limit and to that level that he can kill someone. Obviously the person who is suffer is not innocent either. Something, some action would have led to escalate to the abuse to such a level.
    Please Please think in that directions too.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Salaam Ms. Abid,

    It has been very hurtful and I am horrified to read about this gruesome crime. I pray for the victim and her love ones. May Allah grant her paradise, Ameen. My condolences to the family of the victim.

    Across the board the Muslim community is more interested in arranging Ramadan diners and arguing among themselves when did or will the Eid moon show up and what day we should start Ramadan. Pakistanis don't mingle with Arabs, or Arabs don't mingle with Indians and so forth. Due to these petty issues, people have lost the focus on what should be the purpose of the Muslim community and the Islamic center. Now days people don't know what is the true essence of being a Muslim. It is time to overcome tribal rituals and primitive thinking. Islam teaches us to be 'one', acting as 'one' community, and worshiping 'ONE' God.

    There is very little concern among Muslims on how the people of the local community are doing. Personally I have called so many times to various Islamic centers and have left messages, but no response. In most cases the calls and messages have been related to humanitarian issues.

    Generally in our community, people are judged upon the type of car you drive, where you live, and are you a doctor, businessman, or an engineer. So many times I have been asked what I do rather than how I am. This type of thinking runs counter to Islamic beliefs and prophet's teaching. Shouldn't we be determining or evaluating person's character by his/her actions, rather than the weight of his or her pocket or status. When will we learn. My guess is not anytime soon. I hope I am wrong.

    Finally, my appeal to the community is that we need to start from the ground up. I believe that we need to work on some basics, even before we think about having a Muslim-English channel. First, In regards to the Islamic center it is important that we choose and elect a leader who is well qualified and trained in the role of leadership and is able to connect with the people of the community. Leaders of the community should be listening to the community concerns rather than just talking to themselves and making decisions among themselves. It is essential that people are trained and 'sermoned' to communicate to eachother on consistent basis regarding the well being of a fellow member of the community or an issue related to the community and I don't mean gossiping or talking about the scores of cricket or soccer matches.

    There is no shame in speaking out if it is done with good intentions. In my view the biggest problem our community is facing today is communication and organization. If most of us are well connected in the community and if someone witnesses an alarming situation such as domestic abuse, fraud or anything for that matter then the matter can be taken to the proper authority immediately (leader of the center or police, before it is too late as it was in this case. In this day and age communication among us should not be a monumental challenge given the technology we have at our disposal.

    People who have expertise in their particular field should be given the benefit of doubt. One does not have to be a big shot to propose or organize an event or a project. It is important to allow people to grow. It is relevant that we empower fellow friends, brothers and sisters. It is wise to allow young minds express ideas and serious consideration should be given to good ideas.

    The arbitrary decisions and absolute control in Masjids and various organizations is wrong and against Islam. Newly elected and diverse leadership should be welcomed annually. People should be acknowledged and rewarded for their contributions and voluntary work in their community. It is everyone's responsibility to check and make sure where their donations are going and for what purposes. If the organization is not registered in the United States and is not transparent then one should not donate to it. Asking for the information is not impolite. Personally I feel that person's initial focus should be on the community that he or she lives in.

    Communities must understand that when we live in a foreign country we must try to assimilate in the local non-Muslim community. I am not saying that we should compromise on our faith, but there is no harm in inviting your fellow non-Muslim neighbor for dinner or Iftar. Back your words with actions. They can learn something about us and from us and we can learn something from them. It is not only good for us, but also for our children. Prophet used to accommodate non-Muslims visiting delegations very well at his residence in Medina. Prophet also stressed on inter-faith dialogue. We should follow his footsteps.

    In the final analysis, we need to bring fundamental changes in the way we do things. It is time to engage in constructive and productive dialogue. No time for bickering and arguing. Only then we will be able to come with robust solutions and hopefully avoid this kind of incident. It is time to 'change'.

    Regards,

    Faisal Khan

    ReplyDelete
  16. Maybe people have forgotten the very common terms "bipolar" and also "double personality." In every religion & in every civilized society ANGER is haram. In our culture people think anger is a symbol of being strong and powerful. Men usually exibit their anger in front of every body on small issues & it is acceptable. Unfortunately in our society always women have to face all these mentally sick people. In my opinion if somebody has that kind of anger in himself or herself then first they should get treated rather than going into several marriages and divorces. I agree with Zerqa Abid 's comments & hope this shameful incidence will open the eyes of Muslims.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Salaam,

    This note is in response to Mr. Ali's comment that "busy-talk" has started from all sides. Muslim-haters are taking it as an opportunity to malign Islam and Muslims and their leadership".

    I don't know if this statement was directed to my comments on this blog or someone else. Good ideas and finding solutions is by no means a "busy-talk". One thing I must stress again is that we need to look at ourselves and our institutions the way we do things, and I must emphasize also that I am not encouraging to compromise our religion, but to advance new applications and cultivate new ideas.

    In many corners of this country the leadership has failed, but that does not mean that it can not change. By bringing positive changes is not UN-Islamic. A more of a strategic and vocational approach is required that is aligned with Islamic code of conduct and conventional thinking as well. People should be encouraged to seek professional counseling. I have witnessed that so many people have difficulty venting out their stress in a proper manner. Keeping things inside can be very damaging. As it was unfortunately in this case. An immediate and serious discussion is required in our community and in the Islamic centers about these issues.

    Leaders of the Islamic centers and people in general should take the initiative if he or she observes or is approached about a (personal) problem related to fellow brother or sister. Due to privacy and respect I will not name the person or the center. Not to long ago I know one person who called a well known Islamic center about his intentions of divorcing. He was told by the Imam that Masjid "are for marriages not for divorces". However, the person was addressed about the proper procedures and steps according to Sharia in regards to completing the divorce. Personally I feel that the Imam should have asked this gentleman to come to Masjid to discuss further. Maybe by talking to this person and his wife the marriage could have been salvaged or maybe not, but the opportunity was lost.

    furthermore, Women must be encouraged to speak out against abuse of all sort, particularly the physical abuse. Again the leadership has to play a major role in this by creating and fostering an environment in the Islamic centers and also addressing to the community where women and men can speak out in confidence to their respective leader of the center or a designated counselor. People should also be inspired to hear out their fellow brothers and sisters and also to approach that person if they feel he/she is in distress. If one witnesses or hears about a physical abuse that should be reported to police or the victim should be encouraged and supported to contact the police. Again, a healthy debate and dialogue should start to take place in every Islamic center and overall in the community.

    Due to cultural burden and stigma people are reluctant to express their personal issues to the leader or even to a close friend. In addition, many women are afraid to speak out, because they feel they will be left out in isolation and even perhaps somewhat abandoned from the community. They also fear emotional and/or physical abuse from their spouse. They feel that either they will be persuaded to put up with dysfunctional relationship and/or accept the way things are. So in many cases they tend to keep things to themselves which eventually leads to more frustration and anxiety which can become very unhealthy for the individual.

    Islam encourages men and women with personal issues to reach out for help to their families, close friends, and/or leader of the community.

    My intentions are to start a discourse on these issues and hopefully new ideas and methods will gain support to ensure a healthy, strong and vibrant community. Not a "secular", but rather a common sense approach is much needed.

    Best,
    Faisal

    ReplyDelete
  18. Faisal,
    What we are talking about is a journey on a very difficult path. Knowing our community and our enemies, it's like putting ourselves in serious troubles. Just for the sake Allah and then for the sake of this community, I am with you. You will hear more on this soon, I promise. Thank you for your support.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thank you for our willingness to share this with the blogosphere. It's sad to see how important image is in this country and this culture in spite of all the righteous howling self-professed Christians we have running around, a lousy person can go far with a smile and a handshake.

    ReplyDelete
  20. p.s. here are my own thoughts on this tragedy.

    http://justice4claire.blogspot.com/2009/02/muzzammil-hassan-shoots-us-all-in-foot.html

    peace

    ReplyDelete
  21. I am in United States for last 40 years.We do not like to check past history of any religious personality. I know personally some corrupt leaders but we do not like to bring them in open instead we like to brush under the carpet. behind Quran,sunah and Islam these so called religious people destroying the trust of new generation. this Hassan Guy should be slaughter also.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I know hindsight is 20:20, but Sr. Zerqa, you had many reasons to come forth with this type of information before the tragedy, the highest of which was to protect a woman, and the lowest of which is to protect a community.

    Since Muzzammil was a leader in the Muslim community, it was incumbent for people who knew about his past to bring his "issues" to light, so that the community wouldn't be duped.

    Perhaps this is a wake-up call to all, to stand up for truth and justice, even when it's inconvenient.

    This is a tragedy upon a tragedy. May Allah have mercy upon us all.

    Post on MuslimMatters

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous said...
    "Obviously the person who is suffer is not innocent either. Something, some action would have led to escalate to the abuse to such a level."

    In answer to anonymous post

    Well! this is tipical Pakistani approach where women are raped/killed because their uncle/father/brother/cousin has kidnapped someone but the victim is always accused of some wrong doing. Very interesting! Didn't it says that he already divorced two wives and killed the third one. Do we need to think or say more.

    ReplyDelete
  24. bismillah was salamu alaykum.

    jazak Allah khayr for posting this article.

    taken with all the comments, i see a clash between cultural reticence and religious injunctions, exacerbated by a lack of knowledge about the latter.

    i do not believe that Islam restrained those people who knew this was a violent man from revealing that information to the future spouses and their families. i think culture played many dark roles here: (1) downplaying or discounting the suffering of the prior spouses, (2) accepting at face value whatever excuses the man might have offered -- when repeated violence is evidence of a behavior trait and cannot be simply explained away, and perhaps even (3) valuing the marriage itself over the safety of the women.

    i mention the last only because there is an inordinate amount of pressure in south asian (indopakistani) families to marry, especially on women. alhamdolillah, with several years of experience, i can say that i know for a fact my brothers-in-law are wonderful men, but i also know how many times my own parents said the word "compromise" to my sisters about "candidates" they rejected.

    the greatest tragedy here -- without doubt in my opinion -- is that women are so easily married off to violent men, men known to have been so violent the marriage ended in divorce because of it.

    yes, Muslims in America are maligned and impugned by this heinous act, and by our collective irresponsibility for elevating this man to the point from which he fell so far. but you know what? there have been other debacles. maybe in other spheres -- this is our first/worst incident in broadcasting in this country. but we have witnessed a lot of poor judgment. a lot of wasted money. a lot of broken trusts.

    i can't think of any of them that killed a woman, though. this tragedy is a human one, it surpasses terms like Muslim or non-Muslim. i would be as outraged if the killer were non-Muslim. if the victim were non-Muslim.

    unless we as a community address the shortcomings in our adherence to Islam that exposed this victim to her danger, we should fear Allah that He may hold us accountable for every tragedy to follow, the ones we never pay attention to just because we are not all wearing egg on our face. subhanAllah.

    i am no scholar -- but i know that a woman does not have to ask the specific question "is he a violent man?" just to get that advice from those who know. this is clearly evidenced by one part of the famous hadith of the Prophet sull Allaho alayhi wa sallam in which he counseled a woman who was considering multiple proposals she had received at once. remember his advice regarding one of them? he warned her that one of the men was known for being very hard with women. subhanAllah -- not for being so violent that his ex-wife was traumatized for years! just for being hard with women.

    anyone who thinks Islam would prevent them from revealing knowledge of serious domestic violence (or even severe emotional abuse) is undoubtedly mistaken.

    a relevant question that a scholar could expound on would be the proper procedure for disclosure (1) before marriage vs. (2) after marriage.

    i can imagine that a spouse could have been violent at one time and then repents and reforms 100%. and i do not want any abuser to despair of the Mercy of Allah -- but i do not want any Muslimah to be so utterly abandoned by her community as was sister Aasiya.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous said: "Well! this is tipical Pakistani approach where women are raped/killed because their uncle/father/brother/cousin has kidnapped someone but the victim is always accused of some wrong doing. Very interesting! Didn't it says that he already divorced two wives and killed the third one. Do we need to think or say more."

    What is typical about it. American approach is "Innocent until Proven Guilty" Let the discovery comes out and Jury decide. He has commit crime than law will punish him. More over marrying 2-3 or more times is not a crime. Its better to separate than live in an unhappy marriage. In Aasiya case she was doing right thing by initiating divorce but this heinous crime happened.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Dear Sr. Zerqa:
    The situation at hand is a tragedy for all concerned.

    In your blog you wrote, "This support was so overwhelming that he was presented with awards too. Now the pictures of award ceremonies are coming back to haunt us and some of them are already posted on anti-Muslim blogs after the murder of Ms. Zubair. One of the headlines reads: Bridges TV CEO Arrested for Beheading Wife Received Award from … [name of a prominent national American Muslim Organization]."

    The aforementioned picture was with me when I was the head of CAIR (I resigned in mid-2008).

    It is important for you and your readers to consider the following:

    1. We should NOT measure our successes and failures with how hate-sites like littlegreenfootballs characterize a certain matter.

    2. Bridges TV is a business with many employees and stakeholders. It was a first-of-its-kind effort. The adulation this effort received in the community was thus understandable. The award was given to Bridges TV for its work. Muzzammil as the head of Bridges accepted the award.

    3. The tragedy at hand is first and foremost the result of a personal failure by Muzzammil.

    4. Those closest to him - his extended family and co-workers - should have alerted Muslim organizations and law enforcement authorities about his violent streak. Maybe they did. However, I was not made aware of this. It appears from reading some of the media reports that most of Muzzammil's co-workers also did not know anything about his dark side.

    5. During my tenure at CAIR, Muzzammil had approached me with a business plan that I turned down. I felt that the business models was defective and I received reports about his questionable business dealings. Nothing was ever confirmed and yet I felt uncomfortable. In some way, I did my vetting and declined to have a business relationship with Muzzammil or Bridges.

    6. No organization or business can pry into the private lives of those they associate with. It is immoral and in certain circumstances illegal to do so. So how can Muslim organizations be held accountable for Muzzammil's private failings? Holding them accountable will be guilt by association of the worst kind.

    7. Aaasiya's death is a tragedy that should serve as a wake-up call to the Muslim community. Discussing issues like spousal abuse and domestic violence should not be a taboo. Muslim scholars and imams should be more forthcoming in these matters. Women and children are the primary victims of domestic violence. The Muslim community is not immune to these problems. Our religious institutions should take steps towards mitigating this problem. The Prophet (SA) said that the best among you are those who are best to their wives.

    8. The point about Muslim organizations being more diligent about who they associate with or promote or give a platform to is a fair one as a big-picture concept. Muslim organizations in general have a lot of growing up to do. Vetting is just one of many issues for them to address. However, in this particular instance, I do not know how could any organization (CAIR, ISNA etc.) have anticipated that Muzzammil was capable of acting in such a gruesome way especially if they were never alerted to his many personal failings?

    9. Finally, the aforementioned award was given out by a CAIR Chapter at a banquet. Bridges was one of many award recipients. I was asked to hand out the awards. CAIR chapters being independent organizations, did not need my permission as to who they gave awards to. I found out about the awardees the same time when the audience did.

    ReplyDelete
  27. What this sad situation and sisters tragic plight should serve to highlight, is the complete and total lack of responsibility and accountability among "Muslim" leadership, especially self-declared "American" Muslim leadership. This episode is a rerun of other more insidious episodes, from our "leaders":

    1. Having openly and vociferously endorsed Bush in 2000, with no one (up to now) publicly apologizing or resigning for having done so.

    2. The more damning allegations of how/why this decision came to be, i.e. strong relations between Republican operatives (such as Grover Norquist) and Saudi middlemen (such as Abdurahman Alamoudi). Many of which were laid out in the comments to this article which dealt with Obama's first Muslim campaign outreach coordinator (Mazen Asbahi):

    http://www.altmuslim.com/a/a/a/2786/

    3. Alamoudi's conviction for having been caught with $500,000 at Dulles National Airport here:

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A36718-2004Oct15.html

    then led the Treasury Dept. and ATF to go on a fishing expedition for other groups with which he worked and funneled Saudi funds.

    Unless and until there is more political accountability and financial transparency with "American" Muslim leadership, don't expect anything to change.

    Kw

    ReplyDelete
  28. Abusers are often very smart, can appear to be charming and they know how to pick their victims.

    I am from Rochester and I know for a fact that everyone knows about the previous abuse in Mo's life. But he changed cities, started over where no one knew him. A little difficult for people to warn Aasiya, no? Although I am sure by then even Aasiya knew what she has gotten herself into. Poor woman also made the choice to leave the abuse in her life. Bastard didn't even let her do that. I am angered, saddened and outraged. And my worst fear is that, even NOW no one will learn their lessons, people will KEEP supporting abuse and treat is as a private matter. In our myopic view of the world, as South Asians, we fail the women among us.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Faisal & Zerqa ,

    I agree with your comments. I feel one thing very strongly that there is no religion involvement in such type of cases. Unfortunately most of these kind of people always take a refuge on the name of religion and get sheltered by their society(respectfully). These type of cases have occured before, too. Maybe some people can recall the case of one Pakistani female doctor who was murdered along with her eighty five years old father, younger sister & little niece about ten years back. Her husband was a very smart computer person. The police arrested him from the airport but at that time people were suspecting that he had hired somebody to do this dirty and evil job.
    What we heard was that she had filed a divorce case,as he was very abusive and she couldn't take it any more. I don't know the end of that case, because we didn't hear anything afterwards. The bottom line is that we all have seen these kind of cases which are happening everyday in the entire world, in every community & in every religion. It is a very serious social problem and everybody has
    to step up and play their positive role. It becomes more important for Muslims, as their religion and identity have been placed under scrutiny across the globe. I am sure that late sister Asiya had lot of talent and brain, as she gave the excellent idea about opening a moderate TV channel. It became a golden fortune for them as they were among the first ones who started this channel & they got a lot of recognition out of it. I think things started getting worse when finally late sister Asiya decided that she couldn't take this abuse for rest of her life. People like Muzamil cannot tolerate how their wives can file a divorce against them, as it is only their weapon to use for harassment.
    Also, proper divorce always brings division of money according to the law and men don't like it at all.
    The question comes up what we can do now to stop or minimize these kind of cases. You said,
    "What we are talking about is a journey on a very difficult path," but it is not impossible. When people bring the Quran’s quotations without realizing what they are talking about, it becomes very questionable itself (as I have seen somebody's comment on your blog). The real problem is that we don’t have real community services, and nobody takes domestic violence and abuse as a serious crime. Nobody understands the recuperations of this continuous torture, which can result in the form of murder. If it does not go to that extent, then it always creates numerous other problems in society. I think everybody experiences difficult and negative people in daily life and the big majority of these people are the product of their circumstances. Those circumstances usually relate to the bad childhood and negative atmosphere.
    There is a strong need of change in our thinking , behaviour and daily practices at every level. I am not against the presence of Islamic centres in our communities but that place shouldn’t be use to show the power of some groups and their family fun. What I heard
    and what I observed in the centres is also an open secret in itself, as they are running under the name of Islam. Most of the people are very loud and they always like & encouraged their own kind of people. They know how to use these people against the other groups and again it becomes a game of power and strength, unfortunately nothing to do with Islam and humanity.
    In these critical & confused situations most of the women tolerate mental & physical abuse by their spouses and never mention their ongoing toture to anyone in the community. There are some lucky women in our society who are spending their life a little better than others but these women don’t care. If somebody will ask for some suggestions or help then their normal reply is always, "Girls need to get adjusted properly" or "Oh, divorce rate is so high, as girls don’t have tolerance and in our era it was not the case etc…" Then women have no choice, only to keep silent and go with the flow.

    It is really a time to educate our children properly and discuss these issues clearly time to time. Men also need to step up and play their positive role. Women need to be more focused for their rights, as spending a life in abuse is also not acceptable, in the world and Islam. We all have to go back and our soul & bodies are Almighty’s ammanat and we don’t have any right to harm them or provide this chance to someone else. Diplomacy is a good thing but always go with the truth. We shouldn’t promote those people who don’t respect women, especially their own wives, sisters & daughters.

    I hope that this does not hurt anybody's secular, theological, or political views. I hope that my thoughts are not seen as being biased towards any of those views mentioned above.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I just finished my detail thoughts, published
    above and then saw "Abusers are often very smart, can appear to be charming and they know how to pick their victims." so true as you know the truth.

    ReplyDelete
  31. I have been reading all the comments on this blog but one thing I have not understood is that why Ms.Zubair stayed with such a violent person for so long.People who knew her says she was scared of her husband.This is America not a Pakistani village where she can not get protection and why was she still staying in his house after filing for divorce,no offence but looks like money was a factor behind such a long violent relationship.She liked his money more than her self respect.Religion has nothing to do with what was going on in their lives so discussing Islam is of no use.It can happen anywhere and to anyone but a mature and educated woman like her staying in such a relationship brings only one thing in mind.Money.Being a woman and a wife myself,I can say for sure no one can force anyone in a relationship if you don't want to.Did Ms.Zubair try to find out about his previous 2 wives before marrying him.If not than why?Answer:MONEY

    ReplyDelete
  32. salam
    it is good to be self critical but let's not loose sense of proportions here. How many Muslims do you thing go around killing their wives in America? While each life is precious, we must mourn sr. Aasiya's death and develop our educational and social service programs to fight domestic violence, you know that every day three women are killed in America but their lovers.
    here are some statistices by NOW:

    1,181 women were murdered by an intimate partner.1 That's an average of three women every day. Of all the women murdered in the U.S., about one-third were killed by an intimate partner.
    http://www.now.org/issues/violence/stats.html

    ReplyDelete
  33. After reading the posts, it reminds me of the usual cofee table discussion we have in our homes in USA after a comfortable meal with our guest. The men discuss all the problems of the Muslims and Pakistan and end up with no action plan. The women sit down separately and discuss clothes and fashion. Every one go home happy. Every FRiday the so called Imam talk to 500 captive audience and berates the jews and the women without Hijab. He talks about a multitude of issues with no coherence. The average american young adult (male and female) does not understand any thing becuase his delivery is heavily accented.

    Let us call a spade a spade. We do not need to worry what other think about our religion and hide facts. The simple fact is that M. Hassan is criminal who needs to be punished. The other fact is that Muslims in USA do condone abuse in our homes. Let us stop hiding it. Let us make other institutions and social welfare organizations to support abuse outside of the mosques because most of the mosques after they are built by ordinary muslims are taken over by the conservative and power hungry immigrant trustees. Let us collect funds to scholarships to bright students to study religion in USA and not in places like Saudi Arabia. I am trying on an individual basis in this regard. I urge you to start also.

    ReplyDelete
  34. "After reading the posts, it reminds me of the usual coffee table discussion", I agree your comments as your views are very straight forward . At the same time what other people have shared with us is also valuable & given different dimensions to think that how we can stop or minimize these things. As I know for the fact that we can't totally eliminate these factors from the society. Also there is no involvement of religion in this case or any other cases of this kind. I don't understand why people attached these kind of incidences with religion.( May he was doing business on the name of moderate Islam) Women and Hijab have become our major issues & it seems that if we will solve or control these two things then every thing will be ok. Any way I know directly Muzamil's second wife (Zerqa's cousin)and her family and also indirectly Muzamil and his family. I also heard some things about Late sister Aasiya and as she is not alive to defend her self or answer back, so nobody has any right to say any thing negative about her. I know one thing for sure that M. Hassan deserve a real punishment, as I know his real face.
    One humble suggestion for parents and girls, if you know that you are going to get married some one who has already divorced first or second wife, You should meet the ex wives of that person.
    I don't want to write more as don't want to publicized the identities of different characters, who are the part of this very sad
    & horrible story.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Muslim communities r the worst communities ever and yes i am a muslim!Why do i say that...let me explain something about my life.I was married to (and right now in the process of divorce )to a vey abusive man.He was a prominent physician in united states and 17 yrs older then me.When i married him i was 18.Right after that i moved to states and had 2 children with him.i have suffered physical,mental,emotional abuse from him and his mother,who lived with us.He made me cut off from all my friends,family...i was not even allowed to talk to my parents for the last 3 yrs.Every time i wanted to leave there was more abuse,more threats to kill my brother,rape my sister etc.My parents out of cultural pressure and threats pushed me to stay with him.Outside people thought we were great,never realizing what happened behind closed doors.They did not realize i was beaten every time i tried to talk to somebody or made a face in public.I was sick of pretending.I came to point that i thought i will lose my mind.I thought about sucide alot.I knew eventually he would kill me ...it was a matter of time.But i thought am i so worthless.One time his sister told me oh u cannot leave,if he kills u that's another story,but u cannot leave the house alive.Finally i had the guts to leave him,my only mistake i was so scared of my life i fled leaving my children behind(though he was awful to me did not harm the kids)Now how r the muslim communities bad..let me explain.I am not supported by them at all.They think bcz i filed for divorce and did not give a chance(as if 10 yrs is not enough chances)i am destroying my children life.I am selfish of putting my life in front of my children.A women will be send straight to heaven if she patiently take the abuse..bcz that's her reward.All this bullshit and more.I have heard this crap from imaams,to so called friends,to strangers.This man did nothing for the muslim community ever since the last 10yrs i was with him ( did i mention he's a physician)and since i left he so focused to bringing me down ( a punishment as to how i can divorce him)that he is spending right and left.When me refusing to do to religious affair bcz of his presence,as i was told to suit myself bcz they cannot deny him as he's such a financial supporter of the community.Haha ..what a joke.Where was he all these yrs??I been told that he will find wonderful women and me as i women will be ruined.If he tries to give me a chance i should not think twice about it.Yeah right.I don't understaand do our community enjoy other's pain or r really stupid!!
    Who supported me...these americans,who i am all praises.Just listening to my acc,looking at my bruises...they were there for me.When i rented a place strangers give their furniture, mattress,got me grocery dishes etc to make it comfortable.Gave me a shoulder to cry,since i have no family here.Every time that man try to come near me they protect me.For them abuse is abuse,even it happened one time and punishable.What did my community gave me humilation,insults,religious guilts.I am much happier now and so r my kids,even though life is very hard.
    I don't know when our community will realize that it is the cultural bond and break away from it.How many more women will have to suffer.It sometime feels like if u r a women your life has no meaning...u r apiece of property and easily disposable.When will we hold these men accountable for their actions and bring justice!!Do u realize how many woman suffer in the name of islam ??But to us this is just gossip news...done with the coffee, done with it.We need,to stand up and take actions and support the victims,rather then the abuser,and break away from these suffocating norms of society for the sake of our future generations and just sometime for the sake of a human life!!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Ms.Anonymous,it took you a very long time to come out of the abusive relationship but I really appreciate your decision of seperating from an abusive man.I do agree with you that majority of Muslims in USA are just here to talk big even if you look at their own personal lives,they're not practicing their own words.It's a shame.That is why we are being the subject of all kinds of jokes where our religion is concerned It is the greatest religion in the world,but sadly most of its followers have made it questionable due to their lack of knowledge about Islam or their selfish practices.We do need some educated Muslim leaders to come forward and the present ones to leave,go through the Holy book, Quran again and understand it properly instead of twisting the words for their convenience.I am also very disappointed with the Muslim community leaders here.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Dear Anonymous Sister,
    I am extremely moved by your writing. I know what you are talking about. I have helped four of my very close friends who went through the same issues and community imams were doing nothing besides taking men's side. Alhamdulillah, three of them are remarried and very happy in their new lives and the fourth has just won the custody of her daughter and is settled as an established single mother at this point.
    I am happy that you have found some initial help. May Allah reward all of your sincere helpers and may He guide those who still don't understand.
    Could you please contact me through my profile and be in direct touch. We need you to get out of this and then be an advocate for other sisters who are currently living in similar hells.
    Wassalam,
    Zerqa

    ReplyDelete
  38. Muslim community has its share of Evil like any other.
    Every community works towards reform so does Muslim community.
    WHERE ARE WE FALLING SHORT?
    There are many Asiya's in our community and many Muzzammil.
    The biggest draw back is lack of financial freedom of Muslim women specially those coming from Indian subcontinent. I know a Medical doctor married to a woman with high school diploma. She is a good homemaker and a mother of small children and her husband had multiple affairs she SUFFERS. The community is aware of this yet no one can help her. This Doctor has two uncles, same story.
    The courage that the abused woman drives come from her family, friends, community and the financial strength. These women lack
    1. Finances, their names are on the accounts but they cannot utilize without their husbands permission (Is this an Islamic law?), deception to American law.
    2. family support because they are away from their families (generally the husbands family is around).
    3. Her friends probably are controlled by their husbands as how they should stay away from others affairs so as not to create "Fitna".
    4. Community support because their husbands support mosques or Muslim organizations financially.
    REFLECTION:
    1. How can a Muslim women become financially secure? Educate and earn.
    Let us see the hurdles. A Muslim woman is generally expected to stay home and provide comfort for her husband and raise their children (this is at least a ten year commitment) while she is fulfilling her duties he is acquiring a secure job. He will provide for the family a roof, food and clothing and rest of the funds, he KEEPS it.
    WHAT IS MISSING HERE?
    2. The mosques generally run by the funds donated by the men of the community (if you don't believe me go to a fund raising in the mosque all donations are given in the male section of the mosque).
    WHAT IS MISSING HERE?
    3. Imams are not educated in counseling either Islamic or otherwise.
    WHAT IS MISSING HERE?

    EVERY ONE OF US ARE AWARE OF WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE NAME OF ISLAM (ARE WE ABUSING ISLAM?) YET VERY FEW VOICE IT (Hamza Yusuf and Zaid Shakir voiced it), OR IMPLEMENT IT.

    ONE REQUEST FOR OUR ORGANIZATIONS AND LEADERS
    You carry a higher position and a bigger responsibility, please inquire about the CHARACTER and accomplishments of those you nominate and give awards to. This too suppresses the women.

    ReplyDelete
  39. to anonymous: WHY ABUSED WOMEN DON'T LEAVE THEIR ABUSIVE HUSBANDS, EVEN THOUGH THIS IS AMERICA? I'LL TELL YOU WHY......
    1. They don't know where to look for help.

    2. They don't want to hurt their parents/disappoint them/have them become the 'talk of the town'.

    3. They have children, and feel that they would rather go through hell than subject their children to the real trauma/social stigma of a break-up/divorce.

    4. They are scared of mental/physical/legal retaliation from their husbands. One million times i have heard of men refusing to grant their wives divorce JUST to torture them.

    5. They don't have any place to go to after they are divorced, and are not educated enough/worthy enough by their own standards to find a job that will keep them alive.

    6. They don't want to be pitied and stigmatized.

    7. they are 'used' property, and most men don't want a 'second-hand' wife.

    8. The situation is so bad in most indo-pak families that if a sister gets divorced, her other siblings' chances of getting married will go down drastically too, and even if they do get married/are already married, their in-laws will just find it an excuse to label them also as 'dysfunctional'.

    9. They have so lost their sense of self-worth that even though they maybe smart and highly educated, they don't think they can make it without a 'husband' in this society. Ever heard the theory of 'learned helplessness'?

    I have 9 excuses not to leave my emotionally abusive husband (aint physical as yet)... I'm sure somebody could give u a few more.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Maybe his wives didn't listen to him and he beat them, quranic style. Aisha Akbar

    ReplyDelete
  41. As an American born Christian, I applaud your belief community for its efforts in the wake of this tragedy. As most of the posts are 2 years old, I can only hope that there has been some follow through. My heart goes out to the victims of this vile act, your community which will suffer more from this ludicrous trial. I and others can only ask why the American judicial system had not dealt with this man prior. They let him walk from 2 instances of domestic violence. Is it being used as a way to paint your society in a bad light? And now they are giving him a grandstand to spew from.

    Please know, not all Americans view others of different faiths as monsters in the closet. Some of us have compassion for humans.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Thanks for your comment and support. I truly appreciate your sincerity and well wishes for Muslim community.

    Yes, we have been following up with more concrete efforts in our community. In addition to few more posts on this blog, I have also been working as an affiliate and consultant for Project Sakinah, an initiative that is launched in response to this tragic murder. Please visit us at You will find a lot more addressing this and other types of family violence. For fresh write ups, please check our blogs on Team Up page. You may also join us as a member. We would love to have you there. Be blessed.

    ReplyDelete